She Handed Me a Paper Plate, So I Canceled Her Whole Family novel · Chapter 2 of 24

Chapter 2: Card Declined

At the Wexford Country Club brunch Susannah cancels Esther's card in front of her friends, the Lexus is taken at the valet, and a club woman says Esther has told everyone Susannah asked for the paper plate.

Three days after Thanksgiving, I canceled my mother-in-law's credit card from a corner table at the Wexford Country Club.

Daniel Reeve sat across from me with a cup of black coffee and my laptop open between us.

He was Pathlight's chief operating officer, and he had been my friend for five years.

He had come when I called him on Thursday night, and he had not asked me one question.

"The card is dead as of 11:58," he said. "The bank says it takes ten minutes to show up everywhere."

"It's 12:09."

"Then we're about to be entertained."

On the far side of the dining room, Esther sat at the head of the long table with eight women in pastel cashmere.

It was the Sunday brunch she hosted every week.

She had not looked at me once since I walked in.

Brodie had not come.

He had texted me forty-one times since Thursday, and every text was a version of the same sentence: Let's not make this bigger.

I had not answered any of them.

The waiter set a leather folder in front of Esther.

She slid a card into it without reading the total.

The waiter walked away and came back quickly.

"I'm so sorry, Mrs. Kittredge. It's been declined."

"Try it again," Esther said, in the pleasant voice she used on staff.

He tried it again.

Daniel lifted his cup and said, "That's two."

The waiter returned a third time with a face that had no color in it.

"The bank says the account's closed, ma'am."

The women at the table stopped talking.

One of them found something fascinating in her scone.

Esther laughed, high and bright.

"A bank error. It happens. Put it on my husband's account, dear."

"Your husband passed in 2011, Esther," said the woman beside her, not unkindly.

The dining room had gone quiet enough that I could hear the ice settle in somebody's water.

The club manager came across the carpet with his hands folded.

He bent to Esther's ear.

I stood up and walked over, and Daniel came with me, carrying the laptop under one arm.

"There's no error," I said.

Every head at the table turned.

"The card was a Pathlight corporate card. I issued it, and I closed it this morning."

Esther's smile did not move, but her hand tightened on her napkin.

"Susannah. Not here."

"You picked here, Esther. You picked the table and the audience. You were very clear about where everyone should sit."

The manager cleared his throat.

"Mrs. Hartnell, the club has an issue. Annual dues were charged to that card this morning, and they didn't clear. It's eighteen thousand dollars."

"The membership is in her name," I said. "The bill was only ever mine. It isn't anymore."

I did not say anything else.

I did not have to.

One of the women set her fork down very quietly.

Another opened her purse and took out her phone.

Esther looked around the table, and for the first time I saw her count who was watching.

"We'll settle this privately," she said.

"Of course," the manager said, and did not move.

Daniel leaned toward me and said, low, "The Lexus."

My phone buzzed in my hand.

The car dealership had sent a text: Agent on site at valet. Lease on the vehicle was terminated by account holder.

I turned to Esther.

"Your car is at the front door. A man from the dealership is waiting for the keys."

"That's my car."

"It's a company lease. I'm the company."

She stood, and her chair scraped.

"You ungrateful little girl. After everything this family has done for you."

"Done for me," I said.

"Eight years of it. I kept every receipt."

Somebody at the table made a sound that was nearly a laugh.

Esther did not answer.

She walked out through the dining room, past every table, with her back straight and her handbag held in front of her.

I followed, because I wanted to see it.

At the valet stand, a young man in a polo shirt stood beside the silver Lexus with a tablet in his hand.

"Mrs. Kittredge? I just need the key and your signature on the return."

She stood perfectly still.

Then she dropped the key into his open palm and signed the tablet with a hand that did not shake.

A member's husband in golf shoes watched her do it and said nothing.

Daniel stood at my shoulder.

"I booked the pickup myself," he said. "I told them to let her keep her sunglasses."

"That was kind of you."

"I'm a kind man."

I almost smiled.

Behind us, the heavy door to the dining room opened again.

One of the women from Esther's table came out, small and gray-haired, and stopped next to me while she pulled on her gloves.

She spoke without looking at me.

"Esther told us all about Thursday, dear. She said you insisted on the paper plate yourself."

I stared at her.

"She said you didn't feel worthy of the china."

The woman pulled on her second glove.

"I wanted to see your face when you heard it," she said. "I think I believe you."

She walked down the steps and did not look back.

← Chapter 1 · All chapters · Chapter 3 →

Want to keep talking to characters like these? Chat with AI romance characters: AI Boyfriend · AI Girlfriend · Dark Romance · Fantasy Romance · BL (Boys’ Love) · Billionaire Boyfriend · Mafia Boyfriend · Possessive Boyfriend · Hockey Boyfriend · Older Boyfriend · K-Drama Boyfriend · Anime Boyfriend · Vampire Boyfriend · Werewolf Boyfriend · Demon Boyfriend · Fae Romance · GL (Girls’ Love) · Anime Girlfriend · Goth & Alt Girlfriend · Gamer Girlfriend · Tsundere Girlfriend · Fantasy Girlfriend